Imagine a group of 24 people meeting under a tree to make a big decision that changed Wall Street and the world’s money system forever.What was this pivotal moment? It was the signing of the Buttonwood Agreement, a deceptively simple document that marked the birth of the Wall Street stock exchange as we know it. Stick around as we unravel the story behind this legendary agreement, explore its lasting impact on New York as a financial center, and discover how you can connect with this history on your next trip to NYC.
This post may contain affiliate links. We may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase. Read Legal Notice
The Buttonwood Agreement was the first rulebook for what would become the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). Signed on May 17, 1792, this agreement was a pact made by 24 stockbrokers and merchants in New York City.
Why the name “Buttonwood”? The story says the agreement was signed under a buttonwood tree, which used to stand outside 68 Wall Street. While historians debate whether the signing actually occurred under the tree or perhaps in a nearby coffee house, the name stuck, forever linking this pivotal moment in financial history to the natural landscape of early New York. The Buttonwood Agreement of 1792 wasn’t a lengthy, complicated legal document; it was concise and focused on establishing rules for how securities would be traded among its signers.
Before 1792, trading stocks in New York was very messy. There were no official rules, and brokers often manipulated prices to their advantage. This made trading unfair and unpredictable. To fix this, a group of 24 traders decided to create a set of rules. They met under a buttonwood tree on Wall Street and signed the Buttonwood Agreement, bringing order to the market and laying the foundation for a structured stock exchange.
The Buttonwood Agreement had two main rules:
Brokers could only trade with each other, not with people outside their group.
They would charge a fixed commission to make trading fair.
These rules created trust and stability, forming the basis of what would later become the New York Stock Exchange.
To understand why the Buttonwood Agreement was important, imagine how messy the money business was in New York in the late 1700s. The newly formed United States was grappling with war debts from the Revolution. Alexander Hamilton, the first Secretary of the Treasury, had engineered a plan to consolidate these debts by issuing government bonds (securities). This created the first major market for trading securities in America.
However, this market was chaotic:
The brokers and merchants who would later sign the Buttonwood Agreement saw this disorder as a threat to their business and the nation’s fledgling financial system. They needed a way to trade more efficiently, reliably, and exclusively, cutting out the unpredictable auctioneers and establishing a framework of trust.
The 24 individuals who signed the Buttonwood Agreement were a mix of established merchants and emerging stockbrokers. They weren’t necessarily the wealthiest men in New York, but they were key players in the day-to-day trading of government bonds and the newly created Bank of New York stock.
Their names included figures like Leonard Bleecker, Hugh Smith, Armstrong & Barnewall, and Samuel March. While individual biographies vary in detail, their collective action is what truly matters. They represented a forward-thinking group who recognized that self-regulation and mutual trust were essential for creating a stable and profitable market. Their goal wasn’t just personal gain; it was to bring structure and credibility to the burgeoning financial center of New York. They laid the groundwork for an institution built on agreed-upon rules and exclusivity.
The image of 24 gentlemen gathering under a sprawling buttonwood tree on Wall Street is iconic. Whether it happened precisely this way or nearby, 68 Wall Street remains the traditionally cited location. This spot placed them squarely in the heart of New York‘s commercial activity.
The choice of an outdoor, informal setting (even if legendary) underscores the agreement’s nature: it wasn’t initially a government charter or a grand institutional launch. It was a private pact among peers, a gentleman’s agreement designed to solve a practical problem. This simplicity belies its profound impact. The Buttonwood Agreement was less about bricks and mortar and more about establishing the foundational principles – the rules of the game – that would govern trading.
The Buttonwood Agreement didn’t create the Stock Exchange right away, but it helped start it. The 24 signers built the first organized stock market in New York, and over time, it grew into the institution we know today.
Here’s how it evolved:
Early Gatherings: After signing the agreement, brokers met informally at coffee houses, especially the Tontine Coffee House on Wall Street. This became their main meeting place for years.
A Formal Structure: As trading increased, they needed clearer rules. In 1817, they wrote a formal constitution and named their group the New York Stock & Exchange Board (NYS&EB).
A New Name: In 1863, the exchange officially became the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
Even as it grew, the NYSE kept the same key ideas from the Buttonwood Agreement—membership rules, fair trading practices, and self-regulation. The pact signed under a tree in 1792 shaped the financial world we know today.
The core of the Buttonwood Agreement consisted of just two key provisions, outlined in a mere 111 words:
These two rules, seemingly straightforward, were revolutionary:
This structure provided the stability and predictability needed for the market to grow, attracting more investors and listings. The Buttonwood Agreement created the blueprint for a formal stock exchange.
The Buttonwood Agreement was a catalyst in transforming Wall Street from just another street in Lower Manhattan into the symbolic heart of American capitalism and a global financial center.
Before the agreement, Wall Street already had commercial significance, dating back to the Dutch colonial era (the “wall” was originally a defensive structure). However, the organized, reliable market created by the Buttonwood signers attracted capital and business like never before.
The Buttonwood Agreement didn’t just create an exchange; it anchored the American financial system to Wall Street, setting NYC on course to become the preeminent financial center it is today.
After the signing of the Buttonwood Agreement, New York quickly became a financial hub. The agreement led to the creation of an official stock exchange, giving investors confidence in the marketplace. Over time, Wall Street grew into a global center for finance, influencing economies worldwide.
In 1817, the traders formalized their group as the New York Stock & Exchange Board, later renamed the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). The NYSE became the largest and most influential stock exchange in the world, setting standards for financial markets.
The Buttonwood Agreement of 1792 still affects finance today. Its core ideas have shaped modern financial markets worldwide:
Of course, the journey wasn’t always smooth. The system faced numerous crises, including panics, crashes, and periods of intense speculation. The structure created in 1792 had to adapt, facing challenges like the devastating 1929 Wall Street Crash, which led to significant regulatory reforms. Yet, the fundamental idea of an organized marketplace for securities, born under that legendary buttonwood tree, endured.
One of the most significant events in NYSE history was the 1929 Wall Street Crash, which led to the Great Depression. This financial crisis highlighted the need for better regulations, leading to major reforms in the stock market.
The principles of the Buttonwood Agreement still influence today’s financial markets. The agreement laid the groundwork for fair and organized trading, shaping modern stock exchanges worldwide. Even in the digital era, the NYSE remains a symbol of financial power and stability.
While the original buttonwood tree is long gone, and you can’t simply walk onto the trading floor of the NYSE anymore (security has been tight, especially since 9/11), visiting Wall Street and the Financial District allows you to walk through the history shaped by the Buttonwood Agreement.
Here’s how you can connect with this past on your visit to NYC:
Tips for Visiting:
The next time you hear about the New York Stock Exchange or walk down Wall Street during your NYC adventures, remember the Buttonwood Agreement. It stands as a powerful reminder that monumental institutions can spring from simple beginnings— in this case, a pact made by 24 individuals seeking order, perhaps under the shade of a tree. This agreement wasn’t just about stocks and bonds; it was about building trust and structure—principles that laid the groundwork for New York’s rise as a global financial center and shaped the world we live in today. It’s a piece of hidden history waiting to be discovered amidst the canyons of Lower Manhattan.
The Buttonwood Agreement wasn’t just a contract—it helped start the modern money system. By understanding its history, we can appreciate the evolution of Wall Street, the New York Stock Exchange, and the way global finance operates today. If you want to explore more about the financial history of NYC, check out our article on Wall Street.
Here are some common questions about this historic agreement:
Q1: What was the Buttonwood Agreement?
Q2: Where was the Buttonwood Agreement signed?
Q3: Why is the Buttonwood Agreement important?
Q4: Who signed the Buttonwood Agreement?
Q5: Is the Buttonwood Agreement the same as the New York Stock Exchange?
Q6: Can I see the original Buttonwood Agreement document?
Q7: Is the buttonwood tree still there on Wall Street?
